6th
Close Encounters of the Chosen Kind
I live in a fairly quiet neighborhood in a fairly safe town. The thing is, this fairly safe town has been having a higher frequency of robberies lately, so I’ve been a little nervous whenever I see a van I don’t recognize zip up the dead-end road I live on. Burglars around here have also been known to pose as business people or solicitors, while they knock on a bunch of doors to find out who isn’t home in the middle of the day—prime real estate for theft.
Today, at around 10 AM, I was sitting up in my bed and answering some emails on the computer when the doorbell rang. I froze mid-sentence and considered my options. If I got up and answered the door, they—presumably the would-be thieves—would think me more likely to be home during the day, and maybe they’d be less likely to come and victimize my family and I. But if I did that, I would have to be careful not to open the door too wide, lest they see something inside that’s to their liking. Or, I could simply not open the door at all, not even yell from behind it; but the danger would be that whoever it was would think they’ve just found an empty house. For a second, I realize that, like most people, I’d rather have my house robbed while I’m not there. I don’t know what flavors of characters these people might be, and I’m not exactly dying to put down YouTube to find out.
After a few minutes, though, whoever is outside decides to take to to pounding on the screen door that covers my heavy oak front door. At this point I decide to get up and go investigate. Through the peephole, I see a middle-aged man and woman, dressed professionally, and carrying a stack of papers. They look patient—eerily patient.
Jehovah’s Witnesses.
I grumble and sigh. No, I don’t want another copy of Watchtower, thank you very much. No, I don’t want to know your version of “the truth,” though I appreciate your willingness to come share it with me. I watch them for probably thirty seconds through the peephole. The woman, wearing a dark purple dress and black necklace that looks expensive, raises a bejeweled fist and starts shaking the screen door again. I think she might actually damage the screen part, which is very hard to put back in once it’s dislodged. Once I realize these people aren’t going away, I have to figure out the fastest way to deflect them—kindly, of course.
I breathe deeply before taking the plunge and opening the door.
“Hi!” the woman says before I can greet them. Even three feet away, I can smell her perfume, which is churchy but bearable.
“Hi,” I say, my weariness with this whole routine, this dance between prophet and potential convert, quite evident.
“Hi, we’re just stopping by to bring people like yourself the good news,” she continues. I figure this is the beginning of a long spiel, and it must have shown in my face. “We’re trying to be very brief today,” she offers.
I open my mouth to say something, but she holds up a copy of the Watchtower and intervenes with, “Have you seen this before?” It strikes me as odd that her tone is identical to one a mall salesman might use to get me to try some nasty health smoothie.
“Uh, yeah,” I say, sheepishly. “I’ll take one.”
“Only if you’re going to read it,” she says, smiling and holding it back from my extended hand.
At this point I feel like I’m twelve. I’m wondering if I maybe look twelve, not eighteen. I also feel like being a little smart with this lady, which wouldn’t exactly be nice. No, I’m not going to read it, I want to say, I’m going to go use it as fire-starter for a ritual sacrifice, or make paper cranes out of it. Something, anything but reading it.
“Yeah, I’ll read it.” I take the magazine from her. It’s nicely printed, and appears professional. “I’m generally interested in religious literature.”
She ignores my comment and gets on with her pitch. “Would you like to know the truth?” the woman says, like there’s multiple answers to that question.
“Yes, but I—”
“Then read that,” she says, and taps the magazine I hold in my hands.
For a second I’m tempted to cut the cord on this awkward conversation by telling her I’m a Satanist and currently in the middle of building a new altar, just like the one Christine O’Donnell has. I wonder if she’ll know who O’Donnell is, though, so I ditch the joke.
“Yeah, I will.” I turn to close the door.
“Are you a believer in Jesus Christ?”
I stand there and stare at her. I don’t intend to stare, it just happens. This is getting slightly ridiculous. I feel like I’m taking an online quiz where the questions are read aloud to me. I don’t have an answer to her question; there’s no right answer. If I say no, I’m inclined to think I’ll hear pleas to turn away from my own incoming demise, to rescue myself from the fire and brimstone I’m destined to face. If I say yes, then I’m probably opening a door that won’t easily be closed. No pun intended, I think, as I stand in my front door in my pajamas and continue to speak on a deeply personal subject with two complete strangers.
“Can I ask you a question?” I say. I feel I’ve given them a few minutes of painfully uncomfortable speaking time, so it’s my turn.
“Sure,” she says, seeming slightly puzzled by my query.
“You’re a Jehovah’s Witness, correct?”
“Yes,” the woman says, with a subtle hint of pride in her voice. The man nods nobly. “Yes, we are.”
“So, correct me if I’m wrong here, but you guys believe that literally 144,000 people will go to heaven, as the Bible indicates?”
“Of course,” she responds. “Well, that’s only one of our many beliefs. We’re not as simplistic as people like to make us out as. For instance—”
“Well, I’d like to know more about that one, if that’s okay,” I say. “I mean, there are over six billion people in the world. Isn’t 144,000 an awfully tiny number?”
The man and the woman stare at me. The woman’s smile has faded slightly by now.
“Wait,” I say, “aren’t there more than 144,000 Jehovah’s Witnesses? How can all of you go to heaven? Doesn’t that mean that there are millions of devout Jehovah’s Witnesses who won’t make it to paradise?” [Update: the most recent Watch Tower Society figure is about 7.3 million.]
The expression on the woman’s face is one of annoyance and horror. But I give her credit for still being able to smile, even a little.
“Why would I join your religion if it’s like playing the lottery?”
“Like I said before,” she says, firmly, “there is more to our religion than that. Do you—”
“I understand that, but this is a pretty major thing, I think. Going to heaven and all that.”
“Well, yes, but…” she sighs. At this point I know we’re both thinking it would be easier if her and her companion simply ambled up to another less-informed, more willing doorstep.
“And, I’m sorry, you’ll have to excuse me, but didn’t an editor of the Watch Tower Society predict that Christ’s so-called thousand-year reign would begin in 1925, and then again around 1975?” [Update: Charles Taze Russell, the founder of the Watch Tower Society, made the 1925 prediction, and the 1975 prediction was a result of general consensus.]
The lady frowns and adjusts her fancy black necklace. “I’m sorry,” she concedes, and sighs, “I really don’t know.”
“That’s okay,” I say, even though it’s really not.
“So,” she opines again, looking a bit more hopeful, “I’m sorry, I didn’t hear you before. Did you say you were a believer in Jesus Christ?”
“Which Jesus are we talking about?”
“I’m sorry, I don’t understand.” She chuckles slightly.
“There’s only one Jesus,” the man standing behind her says.
Really? Thanks. Not exactly what I meant. I continue: “There are several versions of him, actually.”
“I’m not quite sure what you mean,” the lady says, her smile twisted upward in one corner, warped into a not-quite-hidden smirk. For a second I think she’s going to launch into another monologue.
“That’s okay,” I say, and smile at her. “I’ll just go and read this now.” I hold up my copy of the Watchtower. “I appreciate it.”
“You seem slightly hostile, or, I mean, offended by our gestures,” she says, managing to sound even more robot-esque than before. “Is there something wrong with us? With what we’re doing?”
Her honestly slightly shocks me, so I respond in turn. “It’s slightly condescending, that’s all,” I say, as kindly as possible. I don’t proffer any other explanation about how deigning to spend your weekday showing up on the doorsteps of random strangers with a “better”explanation as to how they should live their lives and get to “the truth” is offensive. I don’t bring up anything about the other doctrines of Jehovah’s Witnesses that I find problematic. I don’t make a mockery of their misguided, literal interpretation of the Bible. I don’t mention any of the numerous scandals, widely-criticized activities, or false predictions of Jehovah’s Witnesses or their leaders and organizations. Instead I offer briefly, in as few words as possible, how this whole rigmarole comes off to me.
Her face instantly changes. She seems taken aback that I, or anyone, would resist even a conversation about conversion. But I find it hard to believe that she hasn’t had a door slammed in her face before—something even I wouldn’t do.
“Well,” she says, beginning to turn away, “I hope we’ve been of some assistance. I hope you find the truth.”
“You’ve been helpful,” I offer. “I hope you find the truth, too.”
They say nothing. The man waves and they both step off the porch and begin to walk toward the street.
“Have a good one,” I say, really meaning it, and close the door. I’ll read the Watchtower later. I’ve had enough of being saved for one day.